Waterlands

UPDATEDAUTO-REFRESH 5 MIN

SheepsheadPeak season

Bay · New York

Nicoll Bay

40.71°N · 73.13°W · Bay · South Shore Bays from Jones Inlet through Shinnecock Bay

LOADING MAP

Best score today · 6 AM · Sheepshead

65/100Great
Now
301 PM EDT
Best window
11 PM-12 AMEbb tide
Tide now
Ebbing0.3 ft ▼

Data from: NOAA CO-OPS + NDBC + ECMWF + Open-Meteo Marine · Waterlands engine

Notify me when Nicoll Bay scores 75+

Checked every morning against the 14-day forecast. Free by push and email.

Sign in to set an alert

24-hour conditions · rolling from now

Conditions · 1 PM · now

Time1PNOW
Score30Fair
Tide0.3 ft ▼Ebbing
Current1.1 knmodeled · toward WSW
Wind13 kn NEgusts 31 · steady
Sea stateRough6.2 ft · 7 s
Air temp64°Mild
WeatherOvercast100% cloud
Water66°FObserved

Current regulations

What you can keep here today

IN EFFECT NOW

No rule for Sheepshead is on file here yet, so its status is unknown, not closed. Confirm limits with NYSDEC before you keep a fish.

Seasonality · 52-week view · this week ringed

When Sheepshead is best here

Peak season for Sheepshead · 1 more week at peak

Sheepshead season by week of the year. Peak season for Sheepshead · 1 more week at peak.
  • Peak
  • Shoulder
  • Off
  • Not here
  • This week

Sheepshead in New York

Spot profile

Nicoll Bay

Depth
8-9 ftFlat bottom
Structure
Bay · Outer · ExposedBay · flat bottom
Season
Peak seasonSheepshead

NOAA NCEI DEM, sampled Sep 13 on a 3.4 m grid. Depths are feet below NAVD 88, not chart datum (MLLW), so they can differ from a chart by a few feet. Not for navigation.

About this spot

Fishing Nicoll Bay

Nicoll Bay is a bay in South Shore Bays from Jones Inlet through Shinnecock Bay, New York. Depth is 8-9 ft, with a flat bottom. Its profile reads bay, outer water and exposed.

Waterlands scores 17 species here; the best right now are bluefish, striped bass and black sea bass. It is peak season now for little tunny, red drum, scup and sheepshead, and shoulder season for bluefish, striped bass, black sea bass and king mackerel. Bluefish peak in May and from October through November. Striped bass peak from April through May and from October through December. Black sea bass peak from May through June and from October through November.

Tackle & technique

Sheepshead
Sheepshead graze barnacles and crabs off pilings, jetty rocks, bridge supports, oyster bars and nearshore reefs, from a few feet deep out to about 50 feet. Drop a fiddler crab, sand flea or piece of shrimp on a small, strong hook straight down next to the structure with just enough weight to hold bottom. The bite is a light tap, so keep the line tight and set the hook fast.
Bluefish
Bluefish travel in size-sorted schools and feed where tide pushes bait past structure: inlet mouths, rips, shoal edges and the surf line, mostly in water shallower than 60 feet. Look for birds and breaking bait and cast metal or poppers into it, or soak cut bunker or mullet on the bottom from the beach. Use a short wire or heavy leader because their teeth cut light line.
Striped bass
Striped bass feed where moving tide pushes bait past structure: inlets, points, jetties, bridge pilings and rips in the surf, usually in 2 to 40 feet of water. Fish dawn, dusk and night hardest, casting plugs, bucktails and soft plastics or drifting live bunker and eels, and chunk bait on the bottom in current. In midsummer the larger fish drop deeper or feed mostly after dark.

Nearby spots

Other spots within an easy run

  • Great South Bay

    Bay · 2.0 mi

    54
    Top: BluefishShoulder season
    • Bluefish 54
    • Striped bass 53
    • Black sea bass 47

    17 kt ENEL 3:41 PM · 0.1 ftH 9:38 PM · 0.8 ft

  • Range Channel

    Channel · 3.1 mi

    50
    Top: Striped bassShoulder season
    • Striped bass 50
    • Bluefish 47
    • Black sea bass 41

    13 kt NEL 2:34 PM · 0.4 ftH 8:44 PM · 1.5 ft

  • East Channel

    Channel · 3.3 mi

    50
    Top: Striped bassShoulder season
    • Striped bass 50
    • Bluefish 47
    • Black sea bass 41

    13 kt NEL 2:34 PM · 0.4 ftH 8:44 PM · 1.5 ft

  • West Channel

    Channel · 5.5 mi

    50
    Top: Striped bassShoulder season
    • Striped bass 50
    • Bluefish 47
    • Black sea bass 40

    13 kt NEL 2:27 PM · 0.1 ftH 8:29 PM · 0.7 ft

Scores and forecasts are for planning only and can be wrong. Conditions on the water change fast; check the marine forecast before you go. Regulations change during the season, so confirm limits and closures with NYSDEC before you keep a fish.