Species guide · New York
Sheepshead fishing in New York
Archosargus probatocephalus, an inshore species also called convict fish, sheepie and bait stealer. Listed for the Mid-Atlantic region. Peak season, about 1 more week.
Right now it scores best in New York Harbor at 79, one of 4 New York bay systems where the Waterlands engine is scoring it.
Season now
Peak seasonSeason by month
From the Waterlands saltwater species research: when the fish are present and biting, not whether retention is open.
Mid-Atlantic
Peak season, about 1 more week- Jan: Not present
- Feb: Not present
- Mar: Not present
- Apr: Not present
- May: Off season
- Jun: Shoulder season
- Jul: Peak season
- Aug: Peak season
- Sep: Peak season
- Oct: Shoulder season
- Nov: Not present
- Dec: Not present
Peak: Jul to Sep. In season (shoulder or peak): Jun to Oct.
Research notes, Mid-Atlantic region
A summer fishery in Virginia around the Chesapeake Bay Bridge-Tunnel pilings and nearshore wrecks. Seasonality here is angler consensus, not agency data.
Seasons and limits in these notes are background. The regulations below and the regulator’s own page govern.
Where it's scoring now · 4
New York bay systems ranked by the Waterlands engine's sheepshead score this hour.
Best window today 6-8 PM (79) · Best day Fri, Sep 18 at 6 PM (79) · 51 named spots
Best window today 6-8 PM (79) · Best day Fri, Sep 18 at 6 PM (79) · 155 named spots
Best window today 7-9 PM (81) · Best day Fri, Sep 18 at 7 PM (81) · 76 named spots
Best window today 7-11 PM (78) · Best day Fri, Sep 18 at 8 AM (80) · 115 named spots
How and where it feeds
- Water temperature
- Feeds from 50°F to 86°F, best between 56°F and 74°F.
- Water depth
- 2 to 50 ft of water.
- Structure
- Jetty, pier, bridge, oyster, reef, wreck and channel, in that order of preference.
- Tide and current
- Prefers moving water, with light current.Sheepshead feed on any moving tide, but vertical fishing tight to pilings and jetty rocks is easiest with light current. Strong current drags baits away from the structure and hides the light bite. The last of a tide and early turn are often best.
- Light
- Little tied to dawn and dusk.
- Pressure
- Little response to pressure changes.
- Wind and sea limits
- 18 kt of wind and 4 ft of sea. The Waterlands engine scores hours down as conditions pass them.
Tackle and technique
Sheepshead graze barnacles and crabs off pilings, jetty rocks, bridge supports, oyster bars and nearshore reefs, from a few feet deep out to about 50 feet. Drop a fiddler crab, sand flea or piece of shrimp on a small, strong hook straight down next to the structure with just enough weight to hold bottom. The bite is a light tap, so keep the line tight and set the hook fast.
- Methods
- vertical bottom fishing, jig and bait, dock and piling fishing
- Lures
- small jighead tipped with bait, fiddler crab jig
- Bait
- fiddler crab, sand flea (mole crab), live or fresh shrimp, barnacles, hermit crab, oyster
Regulations
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Synced with NYSDEC Sep 18, 2026.
No reviewed sheepshead rule for New York is on file yet. Check with NYSDEC before you keep one.